A talk page on issues and information for Child and youth care workers, especially in South Africa
Sunday, 19 January 2020
CONTINUOUS PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT...CHILD AND YOUTH CARE IN SOUTH AFRICA
We all said, it was an historical moment.
A panel of seventeen selected child and youth care workers met at the South African Council for Social Service Professions (SACSSP) for a training workshop. The purpose?...the policy of the assessment of Continuous Professional Development (CPD) points for child and youth are workers n South Africa.
Training started with "Why CPD, anyway?" It was clear that some child and youth care workers would object to the requirement now needed to maintain registration as a professional. Anticipated was a set of objections based on the necessity to pay for additional annual training.
Let's start however with the need for CPD.
We were all 17 of asked "Why are you here?" My response was, "How would it be for you, if you went to a Doctor who had not read a medical journal for the last 5 years? How would our young people think if they were served by so called professionals trained 5 years ago (or more) and not kept up to date, somehow, with more of today's knowledge and skills?" As in medicine, so in Child and Youth Care practice, the field has a rapid ever-changing growth in knowledge, skills, concepts of being and of self. The world itself has not stood still. We can no longer say, "I've been doing this for the last 15 years. I know what is best".
That is it ! As professionals we have to stay up to date, to expand what we have started to know and to, sometimes, revise it.
Well, in the year 2020, child and youth care workers in South Africa will have to provide evidence that they are updated in order to keep alive their registration and so, to keep their jobs. Basically, the need for CPD cannot be disputed in the best interests of the child.
Let's start then from there. These are the requirements as set out in the SACSSP policy for the award of CPD points:
In summary:
1. At professional level you are required to to obtain a minimum of 15 CPD points annually or 30 points over 2 years.
2. At auxiliary level 10 CPD point annually, or 20 over two years
3.At least one activity must address the professional code of conduct and ethics.
4. A maximum of 10 points can be forwarded to the next year for a period of one year.
5. Each CPD activity is approved by the SACSSP against set criteria and awarded on completion of the activity.
Firstly, service providers. The problem is that there is money to be made from the provision of CPD training. Everyone and anyone wants to jump at the opportunity. So service providers and their programmes have to b approved by the SACSSP and measure up to the formula for the number of points that can be awarded.
Then we have to be accountable and accounted for.
The advice is for us, now as child and youth care workers to open a file, collect and file evidence of your CPD attendance at approved CPD training, accredited workshops and approved conferences and seminars.
Points for what you do as CPD as an individual can be gathered in a more complex system of point formula. Collect evidence now of any self directed CPD you have done.
In brief, this is a list, without detail, of the areas of self directed CPD you can undertake and submit for point consideration. The greater the significance of such, the more the point value.
Personal wellness, self study, learning programme participation, memberships of professional associations, being an examiner, peer review, paper presentation, authorship of article, book or textbook, formal research, project or policy analysis.
As this is a new, but nonetheless important move forward in the profession of child and youth care work in South Africa, the Professional Board for Child and Youth Care Work ( PBCYCW) decided to ease us into the system by allowing that:
service providers who provided training/workshops of a CPD nature in 2019 will, on announcement be permitted to submit those programmes retrospectively for the allocation of points. What you have done, then in those programmes and what you have done as self directed in 2019 can be used for CPD points.
Now back to the cost. It can be controlled. Most organisations undertake an annual performance appraisal and set out a personal development profile for each staff member and ensure that there are CPD styled workshops or courses to meet the need. If these apply and receive accreditation much of the group CPD activity can be gathered in the workplace.
CPD is not punishment. It has been applied in Social Work for a very long time. Now child and youth care workers in South Africa will be on par with all other professions. CPD separates us from occupations such as child minders and nannies. Registration together with CPD put us well and truly into the category of professionals.
It marks a moment in the history of our professionalisation in South Africa
.
Welcome it !!
Monday, 13 January 2020
LANGUAGE WE USE... CHILD AND YOUTH CARE IN SOUTH AFRICA
This blog is not talking about the language we use when talking to or with young people. It's about the language we use when we we describe behaviour, especially in a written descriptive profile, reports and in discussing young people with other professionals. Yes, there can be a degree of spill over from our professional descriptive language and what we say to young people. That's exactly why we have to get it right. The risks and implications are well articulated in the article: Brown A.M Appropriate language in Child and Youth Care. CYC-net, Issue 85 February 2006/ Best Practice .
Now to the issue of this talk. The question was whether we, as child and youth care workers, can "rephrase" diagnostic terminology like manic depressive (bi-polar) and ADDH? 'the question continued. "When taking to young people about themselves can we rephrase or avoid using diagnostic terms?"
I recall an occasion when a child and youth care descriptive profile was sent to a psychiatrist following the arrest of a 16 year old boy for the sexual harassment of three young women in the street of the local town. The child and youth care worker and the multi disciplinary team assembled the descriptive profile as a developmental assessment. He had three days of assessment by psychiatrist(s) in the psychiatric hospital. The report back was "We can add nothing more to the developmental assessment that you have submitted"....no labels (fortunately), just comment on context, some advice on management and a way forward.
It means that when we do profiling (and talking to young people) we can rephrase, avoid labeling, use purely descriptive language and produce a powerful tool, acceptable to and useful for, other professionals in the best developmental interests of the child.
We do this because it is the language of the child and youth care profession. We do this because we know that labels are damaging in the immediate, short and long term.
Until I came into child and youth care, I was suspicious of this thing called 'self fulfilling prophecy'. I soon learnt differently. If we told a young person, "you have a behavioural disorder", then that's what you get. " Sorry, but you know I have a behavioural disorder!" Same with bi-polar and any other label. I experienced young people 'living into' the labels.
Then, when labels follow young people into other life-spaces, they are viewed differently. In school, clubs, family and community and even into the adult workplace even when the behaviour of the person no longer reflects the childhood symptoms. I experienced children and young people refused entry into, so called 'normal' schooling simply on the strength of a label. In simple terms, children and young people can be given labels which can be inaccurate or misdiagnosed.
Our descriptive language is a professionally learnt language/communication style/ profiling skill in which we do rephrase and contextualise what we observe.
To do this, the formula are really quite simple sounding but in practice it is not that easy.
The first is to learn to use description.
"About every three weeks in a predicable cycle, Luckys facial features appear to change. His eyes seem to pull back at the sides, giving him a somewhat 'Chinese' appearance. When this happens we experience a change in his behaviour which lasts about three days. His way of speaking and addressing staff takes on a changed tone.he refuses to do chores During one of these periods he stole clothing from the boy's lockers and sold them at the taxi-ranks in town. This is a repetitive occurence during those three day periods"
That could be a descriptive profile in strictly behavioural terms.The Diagnostic label was, Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE)... sorted with simple medication. Explanation to Lucky was not that much different from the descriptive behavioural profile.
We contextualise.
We always describe behaviour within the circumstances in which it happens.In that way we can rephrase. Given the life-space situation, eg school ,family, in these relationships, in that company, when this happens, Lucky...does this or that.
I always said that child and youth care workers in my employ will hate me because, if they say. "He was disruptive", or "rude". or "unmanageable", I would say "Don't tell me that. Tell me what he DID and in what circumstances".
Lastly, when the final Developmental Assessments are tabled, if diagnostic terminology is used, state clearly, the source from which they came, the name of the professional, and the tests administered, the results and on what date. There has been a pattern over time of certain diagnoses being somewhat popularised: Tourettes Syndrome, ADDH, Aspergers, behavioural disorder and the like... all held later with some suspicion. Diagnostic fashion seems to change and diagnostic labels have been refuted and changed.... Caution! In one year, I remember,that the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) itself was called into question. (I haven't seen comment on the latest 5th edition).
Child and youth care workers describe observed behaviour in context. That's what we do and that's what we do best as one of our unique skills. We don't diagnose and we don't label. We write what we see and hear. We say what we see and hear. When we do this, we practice within our unique profession.
Sunday, 1 December 2019
WORKPLACE CHATTER...CHILD AND YOUTH CARE IN SOUTH AFRICA
INDISCREET..."Having or showing too great a readiness to reveal things that should be private or secret".
Walls have ears
In the end, the indiscreet chatter experience was painful, to say the least. It was a camp. We were each responsible for a group to talk about the night time beach experience of making and lighting candles on the shoreline. I was given a group of adolescent girls. For the life of me, I don't know how I got there. In an idle of guard moment, I asked one of the group, " Why is your brother rubbing his child care worker (Name), up the wrong way?" ( OR WORSE in physical bodily terms).
Well, as you can imagine, it soon got back to the child and youth care worker and to the whole camp. Breakfast next morning, the child and youth care worker told the whole camp, publicly, that she was instituting disciplinary action against me. Based on loyalty, the camp split. Which meant that the Home split. Those for me said "Fire her !". Those for her said "Fire him !"
The charge was "Making personal critical insinuations to the young people about her professional practice and breach of confidentiality.
The child care worker let it run for a few days. Then at camp breakfast, as publicly as before, withdrew the threat of charges. This somehow strengthened loyalty groups, which on return from camp, didn't go away.
For me, this was an important lesson in guarding what I said in the workplace in any situation. In that instance, what I said, was said and I couldn't take it back. It was out there.
Workplace chatter has serious implications in the... who? says to whom? where? and what?.
Let's talk about the who?
Casual talk with colleagues.
Social media issues advice and then a warning. "Keep workplace talk to work. Those you think of as friends "snitch"and then you can get fired". It would seem that colleagues in the workplace who become "friends" need to have talk boundaries different from personal friends in the community. I think that the social media comment has some truth in it. Experience shows that indiscreet, no boundary sharing in the workplace can hold employment risks. The sharing, in the workplace of things like relationships ( in and out of marriage), tavern life, drinking episodes... in workplace chatter , all too intimate and risky. All too often, I heard of staff fall outs and management gets an earful. "Do you know that she........Do you know he........ Oops ! Management stereotyping personal belief systems and prejudices can click in
Telephone talk.
There are among us at work, colleagues, some whose lives are hectic, some chaotic,and some deeply romantic. One of the colleagues I remember fell into the hectic, chaotic category. She found it therapeutic to constantly share all her problems with all her outside friends on the phone.Passing colleagues picked up enough to put things together. Then came malicious, harmful gossip. Personal life was getting in the way of effective practice....There's a workplace chatter lesson to be learnt here.
The there is village gossip spread into the workplace.
We were interviewing for staff.The policy was that we employ 12 learners on stipend and invite 12 to be volunteers with an understanding that they are the first to be employed if there occur any vacancies. I said "Employ !'. Management said "Volunteer !". "Why"? "I have heard that she was seen dancing at a tavern in the village". Out of interview, the applicant said, "I was young, we all did that".
Management.
Don't be influenced by hearsay and gossip. Staff talk to management can be loose talk. When talk with management becomes a moment of idle chatter, it's often what management is wanting....the off guard moments. "You know, I heard she was struggling with assessments for the Certificate, so she went to two learners in another project and offered them R300 ZAR each to to do them for her.
.. and they did. It's difficult to believe Hey! She seems like such an honest person." Danger !!!.
Advice to child and youth care workers.
Keep workplace talk to workplace talk. Guard the more personal stuff loose chatter and intimacy. Keep it for others.
Advice to Management.
Avoid chatter, loose talk and gossip. It's only when formal complaint is lodged that one can take allegations seriously. Otherwise, investigate the chatter. all for the chatterer to tell the story at an investigative consultative interview with both parties present.
INDISCREET " Having or showing too great a readiness to reveal things that should be private or secret."
Dr Google.
Sunday, 24 November 2019
LEAVING THE PRGGRAMME...CHILD AND YOUTH CARE IN SOUTH AFRICA
Robert Stott was easily 72 years of age when he told his story at a Board meeting. He had been in the'" Working Boy's House", so he had been working and earning for the time given. Having to leave, he did have somewhere to go...the parental home. He packed hie suitcase, said his goodbyes. When he got to the gate of the St Goodenough Boy's Home he stopped, stood for a long while. The leaving experience paralysed him with fear overwhelming. He picked up his suitcase and walked back into the Home and into the 'Working Boy's House. "I didn't have the courage to leave", he said. What happened after that he didn't say.
For all, in those early days that might have been done, Robert Stott was totally unprepared for the transition from Boy's Home to out there.
Instituionalisation had robbed him of his confidence to make it independently.
Is Robert Stott's story of roughly 1947 a story of today?
For sure in 1996, St Goodenough Boy's Home had what I called the "silly season". About three weeks before the end of the school year when the boy's had finished writing exams and/ or about to turn 18 and required to leave the Home...all Hell broke loose. Windows broken, graffiti, stones thrown, food riots. Damage to the facility's property was probably the main feature of the "silly season". At first I thought that it had to do with some kind of anger aimed at the Home and it's programme for having to be there institutionally in the first place. Eventually, I got to understand the "silly season" acting out differently. It was driven by the same Robert Stott instituionalisation syndrome of fear and uncertainty at having to leave the safety the "Home". In the "silly season", the thought was t "If I am unmanageable, then the social decision makers will say, "he is not ready to leave. We still have work to do."...and they did.
In the training and education of child and youth care workers today, we learn that at the point of entry, you are planning departure (disengagement and transitioning). Right? The question is: What is the policy, programme and practice, not only to develop, but also prepare the young person for transitioning?
There are any number of leaving the programme scenarios. Running down an incomplete list: there are young people who will return to the parents (presumably well- enough reconstructed), there are those who return to the nuclear family (reclaimed) and at 18 years of age there are those who have nowhere to go.
I had pleas from a young person. Her plea was that I take action against a facility which at age 18 applied the so called legal requirement that she be released. Her plan was to stay with her boyfriend, but in a very short period of time he sent her packing. She had nowhere to go, she said. So she bedded down under a bridge. She claimed having to beg and being raped. Her claim was that the facility in the first place should not have released her without a permanency plan and then distanced itself defensively when confronted.
So, we are back as always to 'What do we do?"and "What are we doing?" There was a saying in the field that young people should be raised to be 100% independent but that young people in need of care should be developed to be 150% independent as the circumstances when they leave often and most frequently require that. Programmes must then surely address this from the point of entry.
There are policy and programme models to prepare young people for transitioning.
In every-day life-space practice the programme sets out "Never do anything for a young person that they can do themselves and if they can't, then side by side with the young person empower them to do it. One of the policies I remember was that young persons over the age of 14 do their own laundry, including ironing. There are programmes that require young people to budget household expenses and go themselves as an age appropriate group to do the buying. All household expenses were explained in terms of a budget. In the dormitory system this was done as an exercise for breakfast and clothing. The programme also included meal planning and cooking.
Real budgeting is life preparation, so St Goodenough had a project in which young people 16 and over were given a paper budget of R2000. ( in those days...enough) Took public transport and given the names of second hand shops in the town. They were to come back with a list, showing comparisons, of the cost, within budget, of setting up a single room as a living space with the essential items. Using public transport varied. They had to be able to use, with support, as needed, taxi, train, and bus.
In one facility there was a policy, "nothing is given for free...no handouts for personal use" It meant that allowances were adjusted upwards to accomodate the young people's personal expenses. As the programme did get public donations, young people were given a choice of taking value loaded vouchers or cash. They could exchange the vouchers for second hand goods in the stock room. If they chose to buy new at a retail outlet they were required to discuss their purchases with the child and youth care worker and produce receipts.
Phased leaving over time is another model. Phased leaving is usually over three phases, but can be more. The phases are planned to, over time, allow that the parents, nuclear family or the significant other to whom the young person is to be released to take more and more responsibility and reduce dependency on the programme.
Concern is shown that transitioning through semi-independent and independent living programmes (and living spaces)is a missing programme feature in South African child and youth care. There are some, but it appears that there are either not many or not enough.
In the 1960's Brian Gannon helped young people by giving financial, social and child care support to transition into their own living places. He said that he was never disappointed. At that time 6 months after-care was a legal requirement as a responsibility of the facility. It is no longer legally required of the facility, but the external social service professionals can do it. St Goodenough had a coffee club every two weeks for leavers to attend as a support group if they wanted.
We are told that transitioning practice is thin on the ground. The warning lights are flashing in the social media. It is a call for policy makers, management and practitioners to put heads together for policy and professional implementation. Let not the Robert Stott syndrome prevail.
Wednesday, 20 November 2019
SACRIFICES MADE...CHILD AND YOUTH CARE IN SOUTH AFRICA.
In South Africa, social media abounds with posts and comments which either state outright that child and youth care work involves sacrifice or imply that it does.
In 1923 The Revd Noel Aldridge recognised that there was a huge need for the care of boys either orphaned, or "pragmatically" orphaned (as he put it), in an area called Wichwood in Johannesburg, as a result of the loss of bread winning fathers in World War 1. At first he took boys into his own home ...the Rectory attached to his church. His pleas convinced the Anglo America Gold Mining Company to donate a flat, disused mine dump . No buildings. Noel Aldridge erected 6 large military tents on the land and took in boys.
In that same year the great flu epidemic struck South Africa. Boys had flu. Noel Aldridge gave his blankets to a boy with the flu, got the flu himself and died . It was the ultimate sacrifice.
For St Goodenough Noel Aldridge's ultimate sacrifice became the benchmark. Talk of "what I'm losing by doing this" and the Noel Aldridge story would always be raised to silence complaints. The work of the child and youth care worker was labelled "noble"....a "calling". It was expected .
Even now, The deputy Minister of Social Welfare at the National Association of Child and Youth Care Workers (NACCW) said to child and youth care workers that they should not complain if they don't get paid, or if earn only a stipend.
Noel Aldridge gave up his life, so what do you give up?..It's an unfair comparison. Organisational management Government policy and good governance should eliminate at least most of our disadvantages as child and youth care workers
Noel Adridge did have a genuine "calling". But professional specialised knowledge, professionalisation and the career choice to use this, is legitimate reason to do child and youth care work. Being professional is not an add-on to a calling.The calling idea is used as an excuse to justify sacrifices because the calling idea is linked to money.
I was once told by a Board of Management member "We don't want professionals.- they only want money like soccer players. We just want people who love the children"
But, 'Love is not enough"and professionals should be paid for what they are worth.
It really shouldn't mean sacrifice.
All this goes together with the other sacrifices. TIME... Day shift, night shift, 24/7, long hours - sometimes 12 hour shifts. The effects are not only fatigued brains and bodies, the money and the time issues have an effect on our own family life and our own children. We should never have to sacrifice our own children's parenting and care...but frequently we do. Living -in with our own children has its own particular sacrifices. Seldom, if ever, does management ask about how our own children are.
I once did a workshop presentation, discussion. The responses paralleled the concerns I had about having my own children raised in a residential facility.
Much of this has, or is, changing as live-out staff and shift systems replace the old "Housemother" thinking. And yet in some places it still lingers on.
Living -in sounds like a bonus, but it has with it, it's own elements of sacrifice, It comes as a realisation , some time later, sometimes too late, that if you have need to change jobs or retire, you have no place to go. Cash salaries are reduced as the live-in accomodation and food are regarded as part of the overall package. This means that pension contributions are low aa are pension pay-outs.
As I said, all of this can be changed. It doesn't have to be so.
Now for the unchangeables. These really. I think, go with the territory. Dealing every day with the young people's emotional stress and tensions in the life-space has and does have an effect on our own emotional status This is where proper supervision is essential in child and youth care work. In addition repeated acts of verbal attack take their toll. Its a sacrifice against which employers should build in supportive measures to avoid emotional fatigue otherwise known as burn-out.
There is an up-side to all of this, Somehow the sacrifices can be experienced as worthwhile. Noel Aldridge saved a boy's life with his blankets, We save lives with our knowledge, skills and self - our professionalism.
A young man knocked on my door ,. Tall ...and he said "Mr Lodge. Do you remember me?" I said "Yes" although I didn't recognise him at all. He came in. "I came to thank you." He said. I'm on my way to the Great Ormand Street Hospital in London to do an internship. I'm becoming a pediatric doctor and then a surgeon. Do you remember one evening you sat on the end of my bed and said "You are one young person I believe can really make it. You can rise above all of this. Well, that was a turning point in my life....from then..... I've come to thank you".
All the sacrifices faded in that moment. Somehow it all seemed worthwhile. Knowing what I know. Given a chance. I would do it all again.
Sunday, 10 November 2019
A NIGHT OF PEER INFLUENCE... CHILD AND YOUTH CARE IN SOUTH AFRICA
It was to do with on-line, life-space development practice with young people. As a start I suggested the Life-space Interview (LSI), Positive Peer Pressure (PPP), Problem Solving, Problem Ownership, I messages ,the assertive communication style, Natural and Logical Consequences.
That night I didn't sleep well. Round and round in my head I relived incidents of peer influence, both negative and positive It probably started with the workshop opening. I said that what the child and youth care workers were doing was group residential care - better - group residential development. It means that for the child and youth care worker, the group, in itself, is a tool for development practice. In proceduralising Positive Peer Pressure (PPP), the difference between PPP and Peer Management had to be made. All this overstimulated neuronal energy......insomnia.
Someone once posted on social media, "I don't understand people who, head on pillow, just fall asleep. Don't they have anything to think about?"
Came to mind arrival at St Goodenough and the programme's system. It was closer to Peer Management than perhaps I first realised. Three models, or systems of "care for boys" were used all at the same time. The private school model, the military model and the boy scout model. Boys managed boys by having Home Prefects, House Prefects, Platoon Leaders, Sargent Majors. Table Monitors, Dormitory Monitors.
When Masud Hoghughi stayed on a visit, he was unimpressed. "Where are the child and youth care workers?" he asked. "This is a formula for abuse. I want to see your Board Chairperson". He was right. Disturbed young people in that system were given authority to manage disturbed young people. "Where are the child and youth care workers?"
Group peer influence was hardly positive. Boys and Girls Town seemed to get it right. I couldn't.
In insomniac moments, moments were relived.
The mantra ...the repeated chorus was "This is the way we do it at St Goodenough". Child and youth care workers fell easily into the refrain.... the culture. "The boys have their own way of sorting things out"tBut the sorting out was hardly developmentally useful. It was the power of the group, but in this setting, it was negative.
Long story short. Three boys were identified to the police having stolen petrol from the mini-bus and accidentally set fire to the rear of the mini-bust. It was in any case an insurance claim requirement. A very belligerent group delegation "We don't do it like that at St Goodenough" The threats of assault were aimed at me. Interesting that the protection of the peers was put ahead of the convenience of their own means of transportation . It had nothing to do with the behaviour of the peers. It had everything to do with my response. The peer influence system was powerful enough to pressurise staff and attempt to pressurise the Director. The pattern of this type of incident was ongoing.
Another image, another place another time.
Ten year old girl on a three story roof threatening to jump. Peer group at ground level chant "Jump ...Jump...Jump"
Then came the positive peer pressure images. Overtime, different setting , different facility culture. The anonymity of hiding in the crowd peer pressure thing changed dramatically when the same young people were shifted into small group residential settings. The child and youth care role become characteristically one of co-regulation and the orchestration of the group toward positive peer pressure.
The "We don't do it this way at St Goodenough "shifted 180 degrees to be supportive of the positive. The group was now fully a tool in itself toward more appropriate, more coping and more developmentally supportive.
In those sleepless moments many events swirled Thinking back it all had to do with a deliberately designed and created culture. A designed environment if you like. Key words surfaced. Democratic, co-operative ,supportive, social equality. "We have to live together . We don't really have a choice so we have to make it work for all of us," It was not easy. The child and youth care worker was to, and did, call group meetings (called house meetings) at the drop of a hat. At first, unscheduled group discussions were very frequent, but became less and less frequent. Scheduled meetings were a standardised weekly procedure.
The"Ï feel...when you...because..." formula was found to be useful. This was usually the cue for the child and youth care worker to, what I called "orchestrate"the group. "How can we help each other to do this better?" Newcomers into the programme probably experienced the positive peer pressure the most.
Here's an image that surfaced that night.
What I call "food protests". The "I don't like i, I wont eat it. It's not like my mother does it, It's not my culture"stories. The verbal protest is not the main issue. but the acting out in the group setting. Images surfaced of food throwing, plates overturned. into the mouth then spat out food, aggressive approaches to staff. "How can you eat this crap?" Quick, quick, group meeting.The group became quite good at exploring with the newcomer, and expressing their own, feelings, thoughts, content, alternative behaviours, support and feedback. Usually the group would kick off with "We don't do it like this at St Goodenough.
Those night time images confirmed:
Peer influence, is powerful. Positive Group Peer Pressure, especially, but not limited to, the more more intimate group residential settings is clearly a valuable if not an essential tool in our child and youth care work.
Sunday, 3 November 2019
A DISTURBING INCIDENT...CHILD AND YOUTH CARE IN SOUTH AFRICA
This blog has never deliberately set out to paint pretty pictures of child and youth care issues and incidents simply to make us look good. South African reality has its fair share of incident and situation in need of confrontation and a call for accountability. We have to come out and admit to good and bad.
An incident of forced removal hit the social media last week.
With a high practical regard for our culture of rights, especially children's rights and our statutory code of professional ethics, children and families are said to be protected.The video on social media showed the forced removal of a child ( it was said to be in Wellington in the Western Cape?). Surely this is an isolated incident but it disturbed me greatly.
The video showed a contingency of what must have been about 6 uniformed armed police forcibly removing a child from off a mothers lap. Bad publicity for Social Service Professional,..bad publicity for South Africa ,or not, this deserves exposure and comment because in my view, this should never happen again. I viewed it twice in quick succession to be sure of what I saw and heard. The third time, access was not accessible "Content unavailable". Must have been somehow blocked. This happens if someone complains or if the content is of a disturbing nature. Below this is perhaps an anxiety that the visual may possibly go viral. Is it possible that there was fear of the South African Police Department and/or Social Services be portrayed in a poor light?
The reasons for a young crying girl ( I think) to be forcibly removed from her mother's lap by armed police then accompanied away by two uniformed officials are not known. A screaming outraged mother...all of this raises questions.
The first , I guess, is whether there in hard fact, circumstances which would justify such wrenching force and such a large armed police contingent.
I got a phone call one night from a mother of a 12 year old boy. She was as equally vociferous in her distress, but for a completely different reason."He's sitting on the window ledge of our flat in Hillbrow, It's 6 stories up. He has just again assaulted me. He always assaults me. He says he will jump. Please come now." I knew I would never find the place ( before GPS!) My reaction "Call the police" But this video didn't indicate risk. This little girl did not appear to be at risk.
Two comments were made. One was not to judge too quickly as there are experienced situations in which Social Service Professional's presence in a possible drug, or violent situation puts the Social Service Professional at high risk of assault.
Been there, done that, guns and all !! The video didn't suggest anything like that. Just a mother sitting in a chair outside the back door, child on her lap.
I have been accompanied by a single unarmed police officer on occasion, but not for a forced removal . I can however think of situations in which a child would have to be dragged away in what could be construed as a "raid". We used to have a Child Protection Unit in the South African Police Department .One youngster was abducted by two young men. The unit took 3 months to find him. e was tracked to a child pornography film studio in the garage of some property. A storm in and grab scenario.
What we all want to know the circumstances around this incident. We want to be informed of the reasoning behind so many uniformed armed police using force to remove the child.
So then, if removal,placement and separation is really necessary, how can it be don differently?
First prize obviously is to avoid he removal, placement and separation. The need to do this is determined by what Anna Freud calls "Irretrievable harm"...harm beyond repair.It is an ethical move only if all other possible interventions have been tried and failed.
This is where child and youth care workers come in.
Child and youth care workers work alongside the child in its environment. In the living moments of the child's space. A good, tried and tested model of this is the community based programme known in South Africa as the Isibindi Project. I does just that. Trained, registered, supervised and mentored.child and youth care workers work relationally. Generally if placement is needed the child and youth care worker will use orientation and seek consent . One hopes that force then will be avoided especially if Social Service professionals work as a multi disciplinary team to provide a multi faceted integrated programme.... a carefully planned designed strategy to reclaim the life of the child and as far as possible maintain family preservation and restore some level of good enough, safe care
It all sounds very idealistic but in the community based Isibindi model, it has proved to work.
Let's sum it all up. The visuals and the audio of the facebook video of a forced removal by police, for me, was very distressing, It looked,sounded and felt like secondary abuse.
As Social Service Professionals we are bound to accountability. We need to know the who, what and why of this incident. We really need to be given enough information to know if this was a protective move in the face of great risk or whether it was a violation of the rights of child and family.
We need to be convinced that there was really, really, no other way.
We need to know what was tried and failed. We need to know if any other approach may have been more professional or appropriate in Professional Social Service practice.
.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)